This comparison usually comes down to one question: how involved do you want to be in your child's math education? Saxon requires a parent who checks work, explains concepts when the student gets stuck, and manages the pace. Teaching Textbooks handles almost everything automatically through video lessons, step-by-step solutions, and auto-grading. Both are solid programs that produce competent math students.
Saxon is more rigorous and produces stronger standardized test scores on average. Teaching Textbooks is more forgiving, more independent, and builds confidence in students who have struggled with math. If your child is self-motivated and you want hands-off, go with Teaching Textbooks. If you want maximum rigor and don't mind being involved, Saxon is the stronger academic choice.
| Saxon Math | Teaching Textbooks | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | K–12 | 3rd–12th |
| Subject | Math | Math |
| Philosophy | Classical, Eclectic, Traditional | Eclectic |
| Format | Books | Online |
| Orientation | Secular | Secular |
| Structure | High | High |
| Parent Time | Medium | Very Low |
| Learning Style | Procedural, Repetition | Self-Paced, Visual |
| Best For | Independent Workers | Independent Workers, Reluctant Learners |
Take our free quiz to find the homeschool philosophy and curriculum that match your family.
Take the Homeschool Philosophy Quiz →