Both are narrative-driven, chronological history programs that cover world history in four volumes. Story of the World is secular in presentation, covering world religions as historical phenomena. Mystery of History is explicitly Christian, viewing history through a Biblical timeline and weaving Scripture throughout.
Both are read-aloud programs designed for elementary students with activity guides sold separately. Story of the World is more widely used and has more supplementary resources available. Mystery of History includes more primary source excerpts and Biblical connections. For most families the choice comes down purely to the worldview question.
| Story of the World | The Mystery of History | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | 1st–6th | 1st–12th |
| Cost | $15–$20/volume (4 volumes) | $50–$80/volume |
| Subject | History | History |
| Philosophy | Classical, Charlotte Mason, Eclectic | Classical, Charlotte Mason |
| Format | Books | Books |
| Orientation | Neutral | Christian |
| Structure | Medium | Medium |
| Parent Time | Medium | Medium |
| Learning Style | Story-Based, Auditory | Story-Based |
| Best For | Multi-Age Families | Multi-Age Families |
Take our free quiz to find the homeschool philosophy and curriculum that match your family.
Take the Homeschool Philosophy Quiz →